The Old Fireside

4.3

A classic American tavern specializing in handcrafted food. Seed oil and peanut oil free restaurant featuring hand-tossed, brick oven pizza with our unique lager dough, flame-broiled thick burgers, and unforgettable house made fries cooked in 100% beef tallow. Full bar, wings, and more available.

Reviews

4.3 39 Google reviews
527
45
32
22
13

What customers say

Customers consistently praise the food quality—particularly pizza, wings, and burgers—along with cleanliness improvements and use of quality ingredients like beef tallow, though service experiences are mixed, with some reporting attentive staff while others encountered significant delays and inattention during busier periods.

Synthesized from 10 recent Google reviews — we summarize themes rather than republish individual reviews.

Highlights

Delivery Takeout Dine in Alcohol Beer Cocktails Comfort food Liquor

What customers mention

Food7 Wings5 Bar4 Fried4 Vibe3 BBQ2 Accommodating staff2 New owners2

Topics customers raise most in Google reviews.

Location

69 NY-7B, Port Crane New York 13833 Get directions